Watchmaker Argument Essay Topics

“Why do we engage in philosophy? Perhaps no better answer exists than that given by Aristotle … We are naturally curious animals. Yet to engage in philosophy is not merely a matter of being curious about things. It requires that our curiosity be expressed through questions and answer in a manner that is both systematic and critical. To this end, however, the methods of philosophy are many. I enumerate some of the most important below.

Philosophy is analytic in that it analyzes the most basic assumptions that we use in an attempt to understand ourselves and the world around us.

Philosophy is normative in that it appeals to relies or precepts that determine correct and incorrect ways of human thinking and behavior.

Philosophy is critical in that it challenges time-honored cannot of belief in an effort to get at truth or further our understanding of some issue.

Philosophy is synthetic in that it aims to synthesize our views of ourselves and the world in a coherent and systematic manner.

Philosophy is rational in that it insists that reasons be given for what we believe and that consistency, simplicity, coherence, and order of thoughts are desirable.

Philosophy is creative in that it invites us to explore and examine new ways of looking at philosophical problem and issues.”

Andrew Holowchak, Critical Reasoning and Philosophy (Lanham, MD: Rowman & Littlefield, 2003), 4.

Relay corrections, suggestions or questions to
larchie at
Please see the disclaimer concerning this page.
This page last updated [an error occurred while processing this directive]
© 2006 Licensed under the GFDL


Paley's Argument Essay

Exposing Paley Paley's argument on the existence of God is well laid out and quite clear. Even so, it lacks the strength wherewith we can undoubtedly come to his same conclusion. There are a few points that weaken what seems like a solid argument and make us explore different possibilities and conclusions.

In his argument, he likens observing a watch on a heath to studying complex and adapted living organisms. If we were to question how the watch came to be, the answer that it had been designed and made by an intelligent being would be far more plausible than the assumption that it was formed by random events. Therefore, Paley states by the same reasoning that living organisms were designed, not accidentally produced.

This argument lacks strength because it concludes that just because the watch is very sophisticated, it must be the product of someone's scheme or plan. Who is capable of deciding when an object is complex enough to merit the assumption that it was designed, not simply the product of the right combination of materials. There are purposes for a stone that are just as, if not more, important than those of a watch yet we seldom question how a stone came to be.

Paley says that we would be surprised to hear that the watch was "no proof of contrivance." (Sober, p118) He points to the fact that we cannot look at the watch and see the working mechanism without being convinced that it is the result of a plan made by some entity.

This objection caters to the very standardized thinking that is a part of the mould of our society. A link with a designer cannot be made solely on the level of complexity of an object, namely a watch. This form of thinking would have us look at a wedge and believe that, because of its' simplicity, it was not designed but merely existed in that state indefinitely in the past. Making it a surprise to find that the watch was not planned just leans on our weakness to claim most good things as the work of humans and forces us to lower our image of human ability if we think otherwise.

Paley could claim that it is the level of complexity that is proof of the planning. The different metals, not normally found together, shaped in such a way to move together uniformly are proof enough to convince us of this conclusion.

This claim states that random events do not occur on the earth that mix the substances so that all the 'ingredients' of a watch are present in one place. We know from observation that natural events, such as earthquakes and volcanoes, take place and constantly leave substances, like metals, mixed in a very unique fashion. Therefore it is entirely possible that the watch was formed by natural, random events on the earth and not by the scheme of some designer.

Another point that is important is the...

Loading: Checking Spelling


Read more

A teleological argument for the existence of a supernatural designer of the universe

2746 words - 11 pages A teleological argument is an argument for the existence of a supernatural designer of the universe based on an empirical observation of order, purpose and design in nature. It is argued that nature is too complex, orderly and adaptive to have occurred randomly or accidentally. Therefore, there must be an intelligent designer behind the whole process....

The Argument from Design, and the Problem of Evil

1547 words - 6 pages The Argument from Design, and the Problem of EvilThe teleological argument, better known as the argument from design, is one of the well-known arguments for the existence of God. It has arisen out of man's amazement at the intricacy and complex layout of many...

Believing in Evolution

1699 words - 7 pages Believing in Evolution "Darwin did two things; He showed that evolution was a fact contradicting literal interpretations of Scriptural legends of creation and that its cause, natural selection, was automatic with no room for Divine Guidance or Design." (Britannica Encyclopaedia) The traditional Christian view of the creation of the world is that God created everything after much thought, planning and...

Paley vs. Hume This is a inductive argument about the origin and nature of God, religion, and the universe.

1025 words - 4 pages Paley vs. HumeI read William Paley's, "The Argument from Design", and David Hume's, "

Richard Dawkins’ Assessment on William Paley’s “design” Argument

1080 words - 4 pages William Paley, who wrote The Watch and the Watchmaker, believed that anything organized for a function needed a special explanation. He concluded that these things must have been designed by some sort of designer and hence, the “design” argument was established. Paley used the example of a watchmaker as an analogy exemplifying a designer. “We think it is inevitable that the watch must have had a maker.” (Paley : 57) This specific example is an...

Philosophy Argument - Blaise Pascal's Gamble

1226 words - 5 pages Since the beginning of philosophical thinking, mankind has tried to answer the age old question: "Does God Exist?" Some great minds have wrestled this rhetorical question, and out of these minds came various theories. Among these great minds was Blaise Pascal, a French Mathematician, scientist and religious philosopher. As a mathematician, Blaise Pascal has...

Believing in God's Existence

3276 words - 13 pages Believing in God's Existence Theism is a reasonable idea. Theologians have traditionally used several philosophical proofs in arguing for the existence of God. In my paper I will briefly discuss different arguments that have been used to prove God's existence. These are as follows: Cosmological; Teleological; Ontological; Religious Experience and Evil. These arguments are not always persuasive, but that probably says...

Intelligent Design of the Universe

2099 words - 8 pages Intelligent Design of the Universe The search for knowledge about the origin of humanity is as old as its inhabitants. Since the early 1800's mankind has narrowed the debate to creation by a Supreme Being and the theory of evolution. Ever since then, science has been at odds against religion. Now it appears that science is returning to religion. Scientists are finding proof that the universe was created by a Supreme Being. The word...

Charles Darwin and the Theory of Evolution

3324 words - 13 pages It is commonly thought today that the theory of evolution originated from Darwin in thenineteenth century. However, the idea that species mutate over time has been around for a longtime in one form or another. Therefore, by Darwin's time the idea that species change from onetype into another was by no means new, but was rejected by most because the proponents ofevolution could not come up with a satisfactory...

Philosophy Overview

10212 words - 41 pages 1. Mythology and philosophy: the rational and the irrational. Criteria of rational knowledgeMythology - is the way of explaining and ordering what is explained and interpreted. This is a mixture of both reason and unreason, of reason and passions. Is about non-rational or irrational aspects of human mentality. It is the way of thinking what we found around ourselves. Mythology is the way of thinking what we found around...

0 Thoughts to “Watchmaker Argument Essay Topics

Leave a comment

L'indirizzo email non verrà pubblicato. I campi obbligatori sono contrassegnati *